letter_V.jpg

This week is "Colin Week," in honor of our Yale intern Colin Adamo leaving the nest for the summer. Every day we'll post one of his own ruminations on sex and relationships. Today, he takes issue with Psychology Today's answer to our question, "Why is virginity still defined strictly in terms of penile penetration?":

The Psychology Today blog's over-simplified dismissal of Em & Lo's virginity question just didn't sit well with me, especially in the wake of dealing with the touchy topic in my own life not too long ago. No, I wasn't awkwardly fumbling through my first sexual encounter myself. In fact, nobody was: that was the problem.

One of my best friends in the world, let's call her Hannah, would be a virgin by Psychology Today's (and the rest of our society's) standards. Despite the fact that she's slept with nearly as many women as I have and, as she's put it, "given a ton of blow jobs," she hasn't had the chance to partake in the "traditional" male-on-female penetrative sex act.

Hannah's been really frustrated recently by the fact that she'll be receiving her degree while still holding onto her V-Card, a feat that is rarely achieved by anyone these days. But it's totally unintentional. She hasn't spent her four years at college underground or buried behind a wall of books in the library. Her daddy never dragged her to a Purity Ball where he swore to protect her hymen. She's actually rather sexually active, and has been for quite some time. But because she hasn't had intercourse with a boy yet, society still brands her as a virgin--a total misnomer...

Psychology Today seemed too eager to brush off its hands and close the book on this topic. "This one's pretty easy," they wrote. Is that so? What about man-on-man sex? Surely no pregnancy can come of this, yet we'd still be very hesitant to refer to our best gay guy friend who's played bottom to a hundred different partners as a virgin based on the concept of paternity certainty. What about a woman who's never had sex with a man but is artificially inseminated and becomes pregnant? Now a father is involved, even if anonymously, for certain. Yet based on PT's hasty logic, her virginity would still be intact.

Even if you take the evolutionary answer as the truth, this doesn't mean we should let it be such a huge part of our society. There's far too many people out there fighting the idea of ownership of another human being to let the paternity certainty argument satisfy anyone. Sex in our culture today is almost a completely distinct concept from reproduction, and it's about time our codes of conduct began to recognize that. If sex today is about sharing our desires, making ourselves vulnerable, fulfilling our fantasies and being intimate with another person, then our concept of virginity today should recognize that.

It's the sort of authoritative tone we see from sources like PT that put so much pressure on good people like Hannah to buy into these absurd and rather arbitrary standards. On the one side they're being told who they have sex with doesn't have to be the person they marry, and that they should enjoy it and be open to new things. And on the other they're being told their sex doesn't count. We need to abandon these antiquated conceptualizations of virginity.

Anyone who has had to anxiously undress someone else for the first time, be naked in front of another person in an erotic setting, fumble through words of an inexperienced conversation of seduction, or squirm in and out of uncomfortable first try positions deserves to have swiped his or her V-Card just as much as the next person.

-- Colin Adamo


1 Comments

Anathema said:

I remember years ago I was working in the sex industry (stripper at a club that offered "live girl-on-girl sex acts.") One of my co-workers was perhaps one of the most sexually experienced women I've ever known . . . her "signature act" was being double-fisted by her girlfriend. We were idly chatting and she realized that, in fact, though she'd had hundreds of sex partners and had innumerable dildos, fists, and other interesting objects inside every orifice . . . she was, in fact, a virgin, since none of those objects was attached to a man. Much hilarity ensued.

Leave a comment






Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Ask Em & Lo
In need of some sex-related advice?
Email [email protected].

The Doctor Is In
Got a sexual health question?
Ask [email protected].

Do Before You Die
Office sex, public sex, group sex -- tell us
what you'd like to try someday at
[email protected].

A Day in the Life...
Got a job or hobby that gives you a unique
perspective on sex and dating?
Email [email protected].

Sex Dream Analysis
Get your nocturnal fantasies expertly
analyzed at [email protected].

Anonymity always honored!

[Body By Glamour ad]





Em & Lo, more formally known as Emma Taylor and Lorelei Sharkey, are the self-proclaimed Emily Posts of the modern bedroom.

Dr. Kate is an OB/GYN at one of the largest teaching hospitals in New York City.

Check out Daily Bedpost on MySpace.com.